Who shows first? 

Can I muck?

Should I show my hand? 

These are all questions I’ve heard poker beginners ask at the table. All have a common theme: the etiquette and rules around mucking and showing your hand. And while not typically important in the strategy and win rates of poker, understanding the etiquette of when to show your hand is definitely important in feeling comfortable at the table and helping all the players have a good experience. In this article, I will break down the proper poker etiquette on when to flip over your cards and when to toss them into the muck. 

What Is Mucking in Poker?

So what is mucking your cards? Let’s define this term first. “Mucking” is the act of discarding your cards facedown to the dealer. In nearly every situation, this is conceding the pot to your opponent(s), as your hand can no longer win and is now mixed into the other dead cards by the dealer. 

The only exception to this rule would be in a scenario on the last betting street where your opponent has already mucked their hand. In almost all jurisdictions, the last player with a live hand can win the pot uncontested, without tabling their hand.

When to Muck

What are the appropriate times to muck your hand? Well the first and most common situation is when all your opponents fold and you win a pot without showdown. This happens all the time in poker, in all variants, and is within the rights of the player to collect the pot without showing their cards.

If your bet has not been called, then there is no reason for you to turn over your hand and doing so would be to your detriment as it would offer free information to the other players. And in a game of incomplete information like poker, protecting information can be valuable in the long run. 

The next situation to muck is going to be when you have arrived at a showdown and one of your opponents has tabled a better poker hand than you are holding. In this spot, it is not necessary to table the inferior hand face-up, and common practice would be to throw the hand face-down in the muck. Sometimes players may expose the losing hand here instead of mucking in an attempt to look for pity, or to show how unlucky they got, but that is not a habit I adhere to. 

One interesting situation that comes up involving mucking is when a player makes an unsuccessful bluff on the final street of a hand. This is a situation that can go either way and is a matter of personal preference. The player whose bluff is called now knows he has no chance of winning the pot and is offered a choice. He can either table his losing hand and force his opponent to table his winning hand, or muck his losing hand and let his opponent win without tabling his hand.

I’ve always found it interesting how players navigate these situations and have seen top pros on both sides of the coin here. Personally, I like to see what players called me with and will always table my bluffs. Other players strongly dislike tabling losing hands, may feel embarrassed about their bluff in a poker game, or don’t want the specific hand combo revealed with which they chose to bluff and will choose to muck facedown. Either way is fine here. 

Who Shows Their Poker Hand First?

Another frequent question from players, even experienced ones, as different jurisdictions have different rules around this. If there has been action on the last street of betting, for example if Player A bets the river and Player B calls, then Player A has to show their hand first. Player B can then table a better hand to win the pot if they have one, or may muck any losing hand.

If there has been no action on the last street of betting, then the player with the worst positions shows (or mucks) their cards first, followed by the player with the next worst position until we reach the button. This is a common spot of confusion where, oftentimes the aggressor in the hand on previous streets may have been in position but doesn’t have to show their hand if there is no bet. 

There are a few casinos where I have seen the rule of “Last Aggressor”, where the onus to show first is on the player who made the last bet in the hand. However, in the hundreds of casinos and dozens of countries where I have played poker, I’ve only seen this rule in play twice. 

An exception to this general system would be in “All-In’ scenarios. When a player is all in and called in a tournament, it does not matter who shows first and both players can immediately table their hands. I’ve seen some goofy standoffs in preflop all-in situations where neither player wants to show first, but it does not matter so just table your hand. There are still five cards to come and both hands are going to need to be tabled. In a cash game, the etiquette is a bit different, and hands do not need to be tabled in all-in scenarios with cards yet to come.  

Hopefully this clears up any questions or confusion about mucking your hand in poker games. It can be a tricky concept for beginners to grasp, as there are a number of caveats and exceptions that change the etiquette. However, this guide should help you feel more comfortable at the table and know when to slide those cards into the muck, and when to rip over a winner.

To play online legally, register with BetMGM Poker and take advantage of the poker welcome offer.